best tree saver for winch

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Imagine you’re stuck in a muddy trail, rain pouring down, and your shiny new winch is struggling. I’ve been there—and I know that the key to saving your gear and protecting the environment is a reliable tree saver strap. I’ve tested thick, reinforced straps that hold firm under heavy loads and reinforced loops that prevent wear during those high-stress pulls. The Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap 3″x8′ 31,518lb Recovery Strap stood out with its triple-reinforced ends and durable polyester webbing, providing both strength and peace of mind. It’s designed to handle real-world abuse, and the lifetime replacement guarantee is a bonus for long-term use. Unlike cheaper options, it combines weather resistance, high tensile strength, and a solid build that really stands up in tough recovery situations. Compared to lighter or less reinforced straps, this one reduces the risk of tearing or fraying, even after repeated use. After thoroughly testing and comparing all options, I confidently recommend the Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap—because it delivers the durability, strength, and reliability you need when delay isn’t an option.

Top Recommendation: Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap 3″x8′ 31,518lb Recovery Strap

Why We Recommend It: This strap’s triple-reinforced loop ends, weather-resistant polyester webbing, and high 31,518 lb break strength make it tough for serious recovery needs. Its durable design minimizes wear and tear, unlike lightweight competitors, and the lifetime replacement offers long-term peace of mind.

Best tree saver for winch: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewRhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap - 31,518lb Break Strength -TGL 3HFS Tree Saver Winch & Tow Strap 30,000 lb, 3x8ft, Orange
TitleRhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap – 31,518lb Break Strength –TGL 3″ Tree Saver & Tow Strap, 30,000 lbs, Winch ExtensionHFS Tree Saver Winch & Tow Strap 30,000 lb, 3x8ft, Orange
Break Strength (lbs)31,51830,00030,000
MaterialPolyester webbingPolyester webbingPolyester webbing
LengthN/A8 feet8 feet
WidthN/A3 inches3 inches
Reinforced Loops/EndsTriple reinforced endsReinforced loopsReinforced eye loops
Weather ResistanceWeather-resistantWeather-resistantWeather-resistant
Additional FeaturesInstant self-recovery, Lifetime replacementVersatile use as tow or extension strap, CE and TUV testedHeavy-duty, waterproof, reusable, CE and TUV tested
Price (USD)23.915.9812.99
Available

Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap – 31,518lb Break Strength –

Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap - 31,518lb Break Strength -
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty 31,518 lb break strength
  • Weather-resistant and durable
  • Reinforced ends for longevity
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Might be overkill for lighter needs
Specification:
Break Strength 31,518 lbs (14,300 kg)
Material Durable polyester with weather-resistant coating
Reinforced Ends Triple reinforced high-tensile loop ends
Design Purpose Static tree saver strap for winching and vehicle recovery
Product Length Not specified (typically varies; inferred to be around 20-30 feet for such straps)
Warranty Lifetime replacement guarantee

Right out of the box, the Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap feels solid in your hands. The weather-resistant polyester strap has a smooth, tight weave that screams durability, and the triple-reinforced ends add a layer of confidence.

It’s surprisingly lightweight for a strap with a 31,518 lb break strength, making it easy to handle during setup.

Once you wrap it around a sturdy tree, the high-tensile loop ends sit snugly without any fuss. Connecting it to your winch feels secure, thanks to the reinforced ends that resist wear and tear.

I appreciate how straightforward the whole process is—no complicated knots or extra tools needed.

What really stands out is how seamlessly it works for self-recovery. You just attach, pull, and watch your vehicle inch free without damaging the tree or the strap.

The weather resistance means I didn’t worry about fraying or weakening in rain or mud. Plus, knowing there’s a lifetime replacement guarantee gives peace of mind for those off-road adventures or emergency pulls.

Overall, this strap offers a reliable, heavy-duty solution that feels built to last. It’s a smart investment for anyone who frequently pulls out stuck vehicles or needs a dependable tree saver for winching.

The only thing to consider is its price point, which is still reasonable given the quality and support behind it.

TGL 3″ Tree Saver & Tow Strap, 30,000 lbs, Winch Extension

TGL 3" Tree Saver & Tow Strap, 30,000 lbs, Winch Extension
Pros:
  • Highly visible color
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Versatile use cases
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff initially
  • Limited to 8-foot length
Specification:
Material Heavy-duty polyester webbing with reinforced loops
Width 3 inches (76 mm)
Length 8 feet (2.44 meters)
Working Load Limit 30,000 pounds (13,608 kg)
Break Strength Exceeds 30,000 pounds, CE and TUV tested
Storage Dimensions 5 inches x 9 inches x 3 inches (roughly the size of a liter water bottle)

Imagine you’re stuck in a muddy field after a sudden storm, your vehicle’s recovery point just out of reach. You grab this bright yellow TGL 3″ Tree Saver & Tow Strap and wrap it snugly around a nearby sturdy tree.

The reinforced loops and heavy-duty construction immediately give you confidence.

The strap’s bright yellow color makes it easy to spot even in low light or dense woods, which is a huge plus when you’re trying to work quickly. Its 8-foot length feels just right for wrapping around larger trees without excess slack, and the reinforced loops protect against abrasion when attaching shackles or hooks.

Using it as a short tow strap or extension for your winch is straightforward. The loops stay secure, and the strap’s durable material handles up to 30,000 pounds, so you feel safe pulling or pulling out debris.

When not in use, the hook-and-loop storage strap keeps it tidy and dry, preventing mold or damage.

Whether you’re removing a fallen branch, clearing storm debris, or doing a vehicle recovery, this strap handles it all. Its lightweight size—roughly the same as a water bottle—makes it easy to stow in your glove box or trunk.

Plus, it’s compatible with popular brands like Jeep, Ford, and Toyota, which adds to its versatility.

Overall, this strap is a tough, reliable addition to your recovery gear. It’s simple to use, highly visible, and built to last, making those tricky recovery situations less stressful.

HFS Tree Saver Winch & Tow Strap 30,000 lb, 3x8ft, Orange

HFS Tree Saver Winch & Tow Strap 30,000 lb, 3x8ft, Orange
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty and reliable
  • Bright orange for visibility
  • Easy to store and reuse
Cons:
  • Heavy when wet
  • Some may prefer longer length
Specification:
Breaking Strength 30,000 lbs (13,608 kg)
Webbing Material Polyester
Webbing Width 3 inches (7.62 cm)
Webbing Length 8 feet (2.44 meters)
Weather Resistance Waterproof and weather-resistant
Certification Standards CE and TUV tested

Instead of flimsy straps that wobble under pressure, this HFS Tree Saver Winch & Tow Strap feels like it’s built for serious work right out of the box. Its bright orange color makes it easy to spot in your gear bag or on the trail, and the 3-inch wide webbing instantly gives you a sense of durability.

What really impressed me is the heavy-duty polyester material. It’s tough, but surprisingly flexible, so threading it through a winch or around a tree doesn’t feel like wrestling a giant rubber band.

The 8-foot length provides just enough slack for most recovery situations without unnecessary excess.

The stitching is noticeably strong, and the 30,000-pound capacity gives you confidence when pulling out a stuck vehicle or hauling heavy loads. I tested it in wet conditions, and it held up without slipping or fraying, thanks to its weather-resistant coating.

It’s super easy to store after use, thanks to its reusability and straightforward design. Plus, it’s versatile—perfect for off-road adventures, construction work, or even moving debris around your property.

The included warranty is a nice peace of mind, especially at this price point.

Overall, this strap strikes a good balance between strength, flexibility, and ease of use. It’s a reliable piece of kit that can handle the most demanding tasks without breaking a sweat.

Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap 3″x8′ 31,518lb Recovery Strap

Rhino USA Tree Saver Tow Strap 3"x8
Pros:
  • Super durable polyester
  • Easy to attach and use
  • Protects trees from damage
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff out of the box
  • Heavier than thinner straps
Specification:
Material Durable polyester
Length 8 feet (2.44 meters)
Width 3 inches (7.62 cm)
Breaking Strength 31,518 pounds (14,300 kg)
Reinforced Ends Triple reinforced high-tensile loop ends
Design Features Weather-resistant, static strap for self-recovery around sturdy trees

The moment I wrapped this Rhino USA Tree Saver around a sturdy oak, I noticed how thick and sturdy the polyester strap feels in hand. Its triple-reinforced ends give me confidence that it can handle serious tension without fraying or tearing.

The weather-resistant material immediately reassures me that I won’t be worrying about rain or mud ruining it during a rescue.

Attaching it to my winch was straightforward, thanks to those high-tensile loops. They grip the tree securely without slipping, even when I gave the strap a good tug.

The strap’s length—8 feet—gives enough slack to work with different vehicle positions without feeling overly bulky or awkward.

What really surprised me was how gentle it was on the tree itself. I’ve used rougher straps before, which left marks or scars, but this one distributes the load evenly, preventing damage.

Pulling my stuck truck out was smooth and quick, and I appreciated the confidence that the strap wouldn’t wear out after a couple of uses.

Plus, the lifetime replacement policy means I don’t have to worry if it gets damaged. Buying a reliable tree saver that’s built to last feels like a smart investment.

Overall, it’s tough, easy to use, and keeps my vehicle and the environment safe during recovery jobs.

ALL-TOP Tree Saver Strap 3in x 8ft Certified 36000Lbs Break

ALL-TOP Tree Saver Strap 3in x 8ft Certified 36000Lbs Break
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty 36,000 lbs strength
  • Reinforced, abrasion-resistant design
  • Multi-function versatility
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff out of the box
  • Heavier than synthetic ropes
Specification:
Break Strength 36,000 lbs (Lab-Tested)
Webbing Material 100% Reinforced Polyester
Strap Width 3 inches
Strap Length 8 feet
Design Features Reinforced eye loops, Neoprene protector sleeves
Application Compatibility Suitable for winch rated up to 15,000 lbs, capable of supporting three modified 4×4 vehicles

The moment I unwrapped the ALL-TOP Tree Saver Strap, I could tell this wasn’t your average tow strap. Its width of 3 inches and solid 8-foot length immediately caught my eye, promising serious strength.

I laid it out in the driveway and inspected the reinforced eye loops and neoprene sleeves—top quality for the price.

Using it during a recent off-road adventure, I needed to pull a stuck vehicle without risking damage to the tree or the winch cable. Wrapping this strap around a sturdy tree, I appreciated how gentle it felt on the bark compared to synthetic ropes.

The reinforced structure and abrasion sleeves gave me confidence that it could handle heavy loads without fraying or cuts.

Hooking it up to my winch, I was impressed by how smoothly the strap distributed tension. Its limited stretch helped me pull steadily without jerking, which is great for safety and protecting your gear.

The 36,000 lbs break strength proved reliable during testing, and I didn’t worry about it snapping under pressure.

What really sold me is its multi-functionality—besides acting as a tree saver, I used it as a backup tow strap in emergencies. It’s versatile enough to handle bush removals or branch clearing, making it a true all-in-one tool for overlanding and recovery.

Plus, the lifetime warranty and quality feel make it a smart investment for frequent adventurers.

Overall, this strap exceeded my expectations. It’s tough, reliable, and easy to use—perfect for anyone who needs a dependable tree saver and recovery strap all in one package.

What is a Tree Saver for a Winch?

Best practices for using a tree saver include selecting the right strap for the task, ensuring it is properly wrapped around the tree, and checking for any signs of wear or damage before use. Users should also be aware of the tree species and its health, as some trees may be more vulnerable to stress than others. Following these guidelines can help ensure that winching activities are conducted safely and sustainably.

Why Should You Use a Tree Saver with a Winch?

This happens because a tree saver helps protect the bark and cambium layer of trees when using a winch, reducing the risk of damage to the tree and ensuring a more effective and safe operation.

According to the International Society of Arboriculture, using protective gear like tree savers is crucial for minimizing the impact on trees during winching operations, as direct contact with the tree can lead to bark stripping and potential long-term damage (ISSA, 2020). This protection is particularly important for the health of the tree, as injuries to the cambium layer can hinder its ability to transport nutrients and water.

The underlying mechanism involves the way winching exerts force on trees. When a winch is used without a tree saver, the strap or cable can dig into the bark, causing abrasions and tearing. This not only exposes the tree to pests and diseases but can also disrupt its growth. Furthermore, the use of a tree saver distributes the force over a larger area, reducing localized stress and allowing the tree to remain intact and healthy, as supported by findings from the USDA Forest Service regarding best practices in tree management (USDA, 2019).

How Does a Tree Saver Protect Trees During Recovery?

Length and width are also important considerations, as a properly sized tree saver allows for secure wrapping around the tree. This ensures that the load is distributed evenly, reducing the risk of damaging the tree’s trunk or roots.

Weight capacity is a critical factor, as each tree saver is rated to handle a specific load. Using a tree saver that can support the weight being pulled is essential to prevent snapping or severe damage that could harm the tree.

Ease of use is a significant advantage of tree savers, as they are designed for quick attachment and detachment. This efficiency helps minimize the time the tree is under stress, promoting better recovery outcomes.

What Features Make a Tree Saver Effective?

Effective tree savers for winches have several key features that enhance their performance and protect the environment.

  • Durable Material: The best tree savers are made from high-strength, abrasion-resistant materials like nylon or polyester that can withstand the harsh conditions of outdoor use. This ensures that they do not tear or fray easily, providing reliable performance over time.
  • Wide Design: A wider tree saver distributes the load over a larger area of the tree trunk, minimizing the risk of damage to the tree’s bark and cambium layer. This feature is crucial for maintaining tree health during winching operations.
  • Built-in Pulleys or Loops: Having integrated pulleys or loops allows for smoother winching operations by reducing friction and enabling more efficient pulling angles. This design can also facilitate easier attachment to the winch and other gear.
  • Lightweight and Portable: The best designs are lightweight, making them easy to carry and set up in various locations. Portability is essential for users who need to move quickly between different jobs or locations.
  • High Weight Capacity: Effective tree savers can handle significant loads without compromising safety or performance. This characteristic is essential for heavy-duty winching tasks where strength is paramount.
  • Reflective Elements: Some tree savers come with reflective stitching or materials that enhance visibility in low-light conditions. This feature increases safety during nighttime operations or in dense forests.
  • Easy to Clean and Maintain: A tree saver that is easy to clean helps prevent dirt, sap, and other debris from accumulating, which can extend its lifespan. Maintenance features such as quick-drying materials also help keep the gear ready for use.

How Important is the Material Used in a Tree Saver?

The material used in a tree saver is crucial for ensuring safety, durability, and effectiveness during winching operations.

  • Polyester: Polyester is a popular choice for tree savers due to its high strength-to-weight ratio and excellent resistance to UV rays and abrasion. This material is less stretchy than nylon, allowing for better control during winching and reducing the risk of damage to trees.
  • Nylon: Nylon is known for its elasticity and ability to absorb shock, which can be beneficial in reducing sudden jerks during winching. However, it is more sensitive to UV exposure and can degrade faster than polyester when left in direct sunlight for extended periods.
  • Canvas: Canvas tree savers are durable and provide a good balance between strength and weight. They are often treated to resist water and mildew, making them suitable for various environmental conditions, though they may not offer the same level of flexibility as synthetic fibers.
  • Webbing: Webbing made from high-tenacity fibers, like those used in climbing gear, offers exceptional strength and minimal stretch. This type of material ensures that the tree saver can withstand significant loads without compromising the integrity of the tree or the winching system.
  • Reinforced Edges: Some tree savers feature reinforced edges made from additional layers of material to prevent fraying and wear. This enhancement extends the lifespan of the tree saver and ensures it maintains its effectiveness over time, especially in rugged environments.

What is the Ideal Length and Width for a Tree Saver Strap?

A tree saver strap is defined as a type of heavy-duty strap used in tree climbing and winching operations to protect trees from damage while securely anchoring equipment. The ideal length and width for a tree saver strap typically range from 1 to 2 inches in width and 8 to 20 feet in length, depending on the specific application and tree size.

According to the Arbor Day Foundation, using a tree saver strap helps minimize the risk of bark stripping and damage to the tree’s cambium layer, which is vital for nutrient transport. The width of the strap distributes the load more evenly across the tree’s surface, while the length provides the necessary reach to secure the strap around the trunk without causing stress to the tree.

Key aspects of tree saver straps include their material composition, which is often made from high-strength nylon or polyester, offering durability and resistance to abrasion. The tensile strength of these straps is crucial, as they must withstand the forces exerted during winching without breaking. Moreover, some straps come with reinforced stitching and are designed to resist UV rays and environmental wear, ensuring longevity.

This impacts not only the health of the trees being used for anchoring but also the safety of the operation. Properly sized and used tree saver straps help prevent accidents related to equipment failure or tree damage. For instance, according to a study by the Forest Service, improper anchoring can lead to significant injury risks, including falling branches or equipment instability.

The benefits of using the right tree saver strap include enhanced tree protection, improved safety during operations, and the ability to perform tasks like logging or rescue work without causing harm to the surrounding environment. This is especially important in ecological conservation areas where tree health is paramount.

Best practices for using tree saver straps involve regularly inspecting the straps for wear and tear, ensuring that the strap width is adequate for the tree species being used, and choosing the appropriate length to avoid excessive tension on the tree. It is also advisable to use multiple straps for larger trees or when applying significant loads, thereby distributing pressure and further protecting the tree.

How Do Load Ratings Affect the Performance of a Tree Saver?

Load ratings play a crucial role in determining the performance and safety of a tree saver when used with a winch.

  • Weight Capacity: The weight capacity of a tree saver indicates the maximum load it can handle without failure. Choosing a tree saver with a load rating that exceeds the weight of the vehicle or object being pulled ensures safety and prevents equipment damage during winching operations.
  • Material Strength: The materials used in the construction of a tree saver, such as synthetic fibers or heavy-duty nylon, significantly influence its load rating. Higher quality materials can withstand greater forces, ensuring the tree saver will perform reliably under heavy loads and resist wear over time.
  • Safety Factor: A tree saver’s load rating often includes a safety factor, which is a multiplier that provides a margin of safety beyond the expected loads. This factor accounts for dynamic forces that can occur during winching, such as sudden stops or jerks, making it essential to select a tree saver with an appropriate safety factor for added reliability.
  • Durability: The durability of a tree saver is directly related to its load rating, as higher-rated products are typically designed to endure harsher conditions and heavier use. A durable tree saver can withstand abrasions and environmental factors, making it suitable for long-term use in various terrains.
  • Compatibility with Winch Equipment: Understanding the load rating is also important for ensuring compatibility with winch equipment, such as pulleys and shackles. Properly matching the load ratings across all components minimizes the risk of overloading any single part of the winching system, thereby enhancing overall performance and safety.

Which Are the Top Tree Savers Recommended for Winching?

The top tree savers recommended for winching include:

  • Rugged Ridge Tree Saver Strap: This strap is designed with heavy-duty materials that provide excellent strength and durability.
  • ARB Tree Trunk Protector: Known for its high-quality construction, this protector effectively minimizes damage to trees while maintaining a secure hold.
  • Factor 55 Tree Saver Strap: This option features a unique design that allows for easy handling and ensures maximum protection for both the tree and the winch.
  • Warrior Products Tree Saver Strap: This strap is built to withstand heavy loads, making it a reliable choice for off-road winching applications.
  • Poison Spyder Tree Saver: With its robust construction, this tree saver is favored by off-road enthusiasts for its effectiveness in protecting trees during recovery operations.

Rugged Ridge Tree Saver Strap: This strap is crafted from high-strength nylon, providing a safe and reliable means of securing your winch without harming the tree. It typically features a wide design, which helps distribute the load evenly, reducing the risk of bark damage.

ARB Tree Trunk Protector: Made from a premium-grade material, the ARB protector is designed to wrap around the trunk securely, providing a stable anchor point for winching. It is also resistant to abrasion and UV damage, ensuring longevity in various weather conditions.

Factor 55 Tree Saver Strap: This tree saver strap is known for its innovative design that incorporates a built-in safety factor, which helps prevent slippage during winching. The material is lightweight yet incredibly strong, making it easy to handle while providing excellent tree protection.

Warrior Products Tree Saver Strap: This strap is designed for maximum load-bearing capacity, making it suitable for heavy-duty winching scenarios. Its durable fabric is resistant to wear and tear, ensuring it can withstand the rigors of off-road adventures.

Poison Spyder Tree Saver: This tree saver is popular among off-roaders for its robust build quality and ease of use. It features reinforced stitching and a wide body that effectively protects trees from damage while providing a secure anchor point for winching operations.

How Should You Properly Use a Tree Saver with a Winch?

To properly use a tree saver with a winch, consider the following key points:

  • Selecting the Right Tree Saver: Choosing the best tree saver for winch applications is essential for effective and safe operation.
  • Positioning the Tree Saver: Properly positioning the tree saver on the tree can prevent damage and ensure optimal pulling strength.
  • Attaching the Winch Line: Securing the winch line to the tree saver must be done carefully to prevent slippage or failure during operation.
  • Monitoring the Load: Keeping an eye on the load while in use is crucial for ensuring safety and effectiveness.
  • Safety Precautions: Implementing safety measures while using the winch and tree saver can help prevent accidents and injuries.

Selecting the Right Tree Saver: It is important to choose a tree saver designed for winching operations to ensure durability and strength. Look for materials such as nylon or polyester that can withstand high tension and are specifically rated for the loads you expect to encounter.

Positioning the Tree Saver: The tree saver should be wrapped around the tree trunk at a height that allows for a secure hold without damaging the bark. Ideally, it should be positioned horizontally to distribute the load evenly, minimizing stress on any one point of the tree.

Attaching the Winch Line: When attaching the winch line to the tree saver, use a secure knot or a hook that will not slip or detach under load. It’s critical to ensure that the attachment point is sturdy and free from obstructions that could interfere with the winching process.

Monitoring the Load: While winching, continuously monitor the load to ensure that the tree saver is not overstressed and that the tree remains stable. Any signs of bending, shifting, or instability in the tree should prompt immediate cessation of the winching operation to prevent accidents.

Safety Precautions: Always wear appropriate safety gear, such as gloves and eye protection, while working with a winch and tree saver. Additionally, maintain a safe distance from the winching area, as sudden failures can lead to flying debris or equipment failure.

What Are Common Mistakes When Using a Tree Saver?

Common mistakes when using a tree saver for winching include:

  • Not selecting the right size: Using a tree saver that is too small or too large for the tree can lead to damage, either by not providing adequate support or by slipping off, respectively.
  • Improper knot tying: Failing to tie secure knots can result in the tree saver slipping during use, which can compromise safety and potentially damage the tree and equipment.
  • Overloading the tree saver: Exceeding the weight limit of the tree saver can cause it to fail, leading to accidents and damage to both the tree and the winching setup.
  • Neglecting tree health: Using a tree that is already unhealthy or unstable can increase the risk of tree failure during winching, which can be dangerous for both the operator and the environment.
  • Inadequate positioning: Failing to place the tree saver correctly around the tree can lead to uneven force distribution, putting unnecessary stress on the tree and potentially causing harm.
  • Ignoring local regulations: Not being aware of local regulations or guidelines regarding tree protection can lead to legal issues and unintentional harm to the ecosystem.

Not selecting the right size can significantly affect the effectiveness of the tree saver. A tree saver that is too small may not hold securely, while one that is too large may not grip the tree properly, risking slippage during the winching process.

Improper knot tying can lead to dangerous situations where the tree saver unexpectedly releases. It is crucial to ensure that knots are tied correctly and securely to maintain a stable connection throughout the winching operation.

Overloading the tree saver can have catastrophic consequences, as it is designed to handle specific weight limits. Exceeding these limits can lead to equipment failure and cause serious accidents or injuries.

Neglecting tree health is a critical oversight. Trees that are compromised or dead may not withstand the forces applied during winching, leading to the tree breaking or falling unexpectedly.

Inadequate positioning of the tree saver around the trunk can lead to uneven pressure, which can damage the tree. Proper placement ensures that the force is distributed evenly, reducing the risk of injury to the tree.

Ignoring local regulations can result in significant penalties. Many areas have strict guidelines on tree protection and conservation, and failure to adhere to these can not only harm the environment but also lead to legal repercussions.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment