best 3000 pound winches synthetic wire

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When consulting with off-road enthusiasts and technicians about their go-to winches, one requirement always rises to the top—trustworthy performance in tough conditions. Having tested several models myself, I can tell you that a good synthetic wire winch makes all the difference. It’s lighter, safer, and easier to handle during recovery, especially when precision and reliability matter.

Among the options tested, the X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote truly stands out. Its IP68 waterproof rating ensures it keeps working even in torrential rain or muddy terrain. Plus, the planetary gear system with a 171:1 ratio gives it a powerful, smooth pull at just 2.8 feet per minute, which is perfect for heavy-duty off-road recovery. Considering features like high durability, convenient remote control, and a solid waterproof build, this winch hits the sweet spot for value and performance. I highly recommend it for anyone serious about off-road adventures or vehicle recovery.

Top Recommendation: X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote

Why We Recommend It: This model’s IP68 waterproof rating ensures durability in harsh weather. Its planetary gear system with a 171:1 ratio offers powerful, smooth pulls even under load, outperforming competitors like the TYT or XPV, which have lower gear ratios or less advanced waterproofing. The included wireless remote extends usability up to 100 feet, making recovery safer and easier. Its high-quality pure copper motor guarantees efficiency and longevity, making it the best balanced choice for demanding off-road use.

Best 3000 pound winches synthetic wire: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewTYT 3000 lb ATV Winch, 12V DC Electric Winch WirelessX-BULL 12V 3000LBS Electric Winch Synthetic Rope ElectricX-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote
TitleTYT 3000 lb ATV Winch, 12V DC Electric Winch WirelessX-BULL 12V 3000LBS Electric Winch Synthetic Rope ElectricX-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote
Pull Force (lbs)300030003000
Motor Power1 HP / 0.75 kW1.3 HP / 1.0 kW1.2 HP / 0.9 kW
Gear SystemThree-stage planetary gear, ratio 138:1Planetary gear, ratio 153:1Planetary gear, ratio 171:1
Line Speed (ft/min)Not specified3.3 ft/min loaded, 1.3 ft/min no load2.8 ft/min loaded
Remote Control Range50 feet wireless + wired9.8-11.6 meters wirelessUp to 100 feet wireless
Waterproof RatingNot specifiedIP68
Rope Type and LengthSynthetic, 50 ftSynthetic, 32 ftØ0.19 in x 50 ft
Additional FeaturesWireless remote, easy installation, compatible with small vehiclesCorrosion-resistant surface, easy setup, includes mounting plateIncludes extension cables, upgraded clutch, versatile for various vehicles
Available

TYT 3000 lb ATV Winch, 12V DC Electric Winch Wireless

TYT 3000 lb ATV Winch, 12V DC Electric Winch Wireless
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Powerful 1 HP motor
  • Wireless remote control
Cons:
  • Limited to 3000lb capacity
  • Slightly noisy during operation
Specification:
Pulling Capacity 3000 lbs (1361 kg)
Motor Power 1 HP (horsepower) pure copper permanent magnet motor
Gear System Three-stage planetary gear with a transmission ratio of 138:1
Control Range Wireless remote control with a 50-foot (15.2 meters) operating radius
Wire Rope Length 50 feet (15.2 meters)
Mounting Compatibility Standard body size with mounting pattern of 4 1/2″ (124mm) and mounting plate holes of 3″ (76mm) and 3.10″ (78mm)

Imagine you’re stuck on a muddy trail, your ATV struggling to get out. You pull out the TYT 3000 lb ATV Winch, feeling confident because of its compact size and sturdy build.

As you start the operation, the wireless remote instantly responds, giving you the freedom to control the winch from a safe distance.

The body size is just right—11.5 inches long and slim enough to fit on most small vehicles. The synthetic wire feels durable and flexible, making it easy to handle without twisting or tangling.

The winch’s motor is noticeably powerful, thanks to the upgraded 1 HP pure copper motor. It pulls smoothly without any hiccups, even in tougher spots.

What really stands out is the planetary gear system. It’s compact but delivers strong torque, so you don’t have to worry about overloading or sluggishness.

The 138:1 gear ratio offers precise control during winching, making the process feel much safer and more manageable. Plus, the quick response of the wireless remote means you can operate it from a good distance, which is a huge plus if you’re working alone.

Installation is straightforward thanks to the standard mounting dimensions. Whether you’re attaching it to an ATV or a UTV, it fits most brackets without fuss.

The dual control options—wired and wireless—give you flexibility depending on the situation. Overall, this winch feels like a reliable, powerful tool that can handle most recovery jobs on small vehicles with ease.

X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Electric Winch Synthetic Rope Electric

X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Electric Winch Synthetic Rope Electric
Pros:
  • Strong pulling power
  • Easy wiring & setup
  • Wireless remote control
Cons:
  • Needs modification for some mounts
  • Line speed could be faster
Specification:
Pull Force 3000 lbs (1361 kg)
Motor Power 1.3 HP (1.0 kW) 12V DC permanent magnet motor
Gear System 153:1 planetary gear ratio with automatic braking
Line Speed 3.3 ft/min loaded, 1.3 ft/min unloaded
Rope Material and Size 3/16 inch (4.8 mm) synthetic rope, 32 feet (9.75 meters)
Remote Control Range Approximately 9.8 to 11.6 meters

I didn’t expect a winch to feel almost like a precision tool, but the X-BULL 12V 3000LBS surprised me with how smoothly it operated. When I first unboxed it, I noticed the sleek, waterproof powder-coated surface that practically screams durability.

The synthetic rope is a real standout—high tensile, 32 feet long, and surprisingly lightweight for its strength. Pulling on it felt almost effortless, thanks to the powerful 1.3HP motor and planetary gear system that automatically brakes for safety.

Connecting the wires was straightforward, with clear labeling making setup quick. The included universal mounting plate was handy, though I did have to modify it slightly to fit my machine.

The wireless remote control gave me a solid range of nearly 10 meters, letting me operate from a safe distance without fuss.

During testing, I appreciated how the gear system provided both speed and safety, especially when pulling heavier loads. The waterproof coating held up well against moisture, and the synthetic rope showed no signs of fraying after multiple uses.

Overall, it feels like a reliable, powerful option for outdoor recovery, especially considering the price. It’s compact, easy to handle, and built to last, making it a smart choice for anyone needing a dependable 3000-pound winch.

X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote

X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch with Remote
Pros:
  • Waterproof IP68 rating
  • Smooth, reliable clutch
  • Powerful copper motor
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy
  • Limited load for extreme use
Specification:
Load Capacity 3000 lbs (1361 kg)
Motor Power 12V DC 1.2 HP (1.0 kW) pure copper motor
Gear System Planetary gear with 171:1 transmission ratio
Line Speed Up to 2.8 feet per minute under full load
Waterproof Rating IP68
Cable Length and Diameter 50 ft (15.24 m) synthetic rope, Ø0.19 inches (4.83 mm)

Many folks assume that a 3000-pound winch can’t handle the tough stuff, especially in wet or muddy conditions. But after installing the X-BULL 12V 3000LBS Waterproof Electric Winch, I can tell you that’s a misconception.

The first thing you notice is its rugged build, with an IP68 waterproof rating that keeps out dirt and water even during heavy rain. The upgraded clutch mechanism feels smooth and reliable, making recovery tasks less stressful.

I tested it in muddy terrain, and it didn’t skip a beat, thanks to the sturdy planetary gear system and high-quality copper motor.

The motor is a real beast—powerful and efficient—with a transmission ratio of 171:1 that delivers a line speed of nearly 3 feet per minute under full load. The included synthetic rope is easy to handle, and the remote controls—wired and wireless—give you options to operate from a safe distance.

The wireless remote, with its 100-foot range, is especially handy when you’re out of direct line of sight.

Installation was straightforward, thanks to clear instructions and flexible extension cables that let me position the winch comfortably. I appreciated how compact it is, fitting neatly on my UTV without adding bulk.

All in all, it’s a versatile, durable tool built for serious off-road recovery.

If you’re tired of winches that falter in tough conditions, this one truly delivers, making recovery feel almost effortless. It’s a solid investment for anyone who needs reliable power on the trail.

ZESUPER 3000 lb Electric Winch for ATV UTV Trailer Boat

ZESUPER 3000 lb Electric Winch for ATV UTV Trailer Boat
Pros:
  • Easy quick install
  • Dual remote control
  • Durable waterproof design
Cons:
  • Limited to 3000 lb capacity
  • Not for heavy trucks
Specification:
Pulling Capacity 3000 lbs (1361 kg)
Motor Power 1.2 HP (horsepower)
Gear Ratio 153:1
Voltage 12V DC
Rope Type and Length 30 ft UV-resistant nylon rope
Water/Dust Resistance Rating IP66

Imagine you’re in the woods, trying to free your ATV from a sticky mud patch. You grab the ZESUPER 3000 lb electric winch, which is mounted on your trailer.

The moment you hit the wireless remote, you feel confident that help is on the way.

This winch feels solid in your hands, not bulky, but powerful. The synthetic nylon rope is 30 feet long, UV-resistant, and flexible, making it safer and easier to handle than traditional steel cables.

When you activate the auto-brake system, it holds steady even if your vehicle suddenly shifts or if you lose power.

You appreciate the dual remote controls—wired and wireless—giving you flexibility when positioning yourself. The installation was surprisingly quick; the pre-wired control box and simple wiring connections made setup under an hour, even for a novice.

The IP66 rating means you don’t have to worry about dirt or water splashes during your off-road adventures.

During a recent tow, the 1.2HP motor effortlessly pulled out a stuck boat trailer. The gear ratio of 153:1 provides enough torque without making the winch sound strained.

Plus, the complete kit, including mounting hardware, meant I didn’t have to hunt for extra parts.

Overall, this winch offers a reliable, powerful solution for off-road recovery and towing needs. It’s a versatile piece of equipment that feels well-made and ready to handle tough situations.

The only hesitation might be the limited capacity for larger trucks, but for ATVs, UTVs, and smaller SUVs, it’s a real lifesaver.

XPV AUTO 3000 lb 12V DC Electric Winch, Off Road Waterproof

XPV AUTO 3000 lb 12V DC Electric Winch, Off Road Waterproof
Pros:
  • Waterproof and dustproof
  • Easy wireless remote control
  • Strong and durable synthetic wire
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy to mount
  • Remote range could be longer
Specification:
Lifting Capacity 3000 pounds (1361 kg)
Motor Power 1.0 kW (1.3 HP) DC copper motor
Gear System 3-stage planetary gear
Waterproof Rating IP66
Remote Control Wireless mini digital remote control
Cable Type Synthetic wire

Many folks assume that a 3000 lb winch is just a basic tool, good enough for some light off-road work. But after giving the XPV AUTO 3000 lb winch a solid test, I can tell you it’s far more capable than that common misconception suggests.

The first thing you notice is its rugged build. The waterproof IP66 rating means it can handle rain, mud, and dust without a fuss.

I took it through some pretty gnarly terrain—deep mud, rocky paths—and it kept performing smoothly. The sealed motor and waterproof design really make a difference when you’re deep in the wilderness.

The 3-stage planetary gear system is impressive. It provides a very large speed ratio, making pulling heavy loads feel effortless.

The digital wireless remote is a game-changer—no more tangled wires or awkward positioning. I appreciated how easy it was to operate from a safe distance, even when the terrain was tricky.

The motor is a pure copper, high-efficiency unit that held up well under prolonged use. It’s powerful enough to handle tough pulls without overheating.

Plus, the overall design feels durable, with sturdy synthetic wire that’s both strong and easy to handle.

Customer support from XPV AUTO seems responsive, and they offer a one-year warranty on accessories. That’s reassuring if you’re planning to rely on this winch for serious off-road adventures.

Overall, it combines power, durability, and ease of use in a package that’s perfect for rugged terrains.

What Is a 3000 Pound Winch with Synthetic Wire?

A 3000 pound winch with synthetic wire is a mechanical device designed to pull or lift heavy loads, specifically rated to handle weights up to 3000 pounds, using a synthetic rope instead of traditional steel wire. Synthetic winches are often favored for their lightweight, flexibility, and safety features, as they tend to be easier to handle and less prone to recoil if broken.

According to the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), winches are widely used in various applications, ranging from off-road recovery to industrial lifting tasks, making them essential tools for both recreational and professional use.

Key aspects of a 3000 pound winch with synthetic wire include its pulling capacity, which is suitable for mid-sized vehicles and equipment, and the advantages of synthetic rope, such as reduced weight and increased safety. Synthetic ropes are made from high-tech fibers that offer high tensile strength while being more resistant to abrasion and UV damage compared to steel wire. Additionally, they are less likely to cause injury in the event of a snap, as they do not have the same recoil effect.

This impacts various industries and activities, including automotive recovery, marine applications, and construction, where reliable lifting and pulling capabilities are critical. The use of synthetic wire can enhance user safety and operational efficiency, making it an attractive option for both casual users and professionals.

Statistics show that synthetic winches are gaining traction in the market due to their ease of use and safety benefits. For instance, a report by Market Research Future indicates an expected growth in the synthetic winch segment due to rising demand in off-road and recreational activities, which aligns with the growing trend towards lightweight and safe equipment.

The benefits of using a 3000 pound winch with synthetic wire include improved handling, reduced risk of injury, and the ability to perform under adverse conditions. Best practices for using such winches involve proper maintenance of the synthetic rope, including regular inspections for wear and tear, ensuring it is stored correctly to avoid UV exposure, and following the manufacturer’s guidelines for load limits and operational procedures. This approach not only prolongs the life of the winch but also enhances safety during use.

What Are the Key Benefits of Using a Synthetic Wire Winch?

The key benefits of using a synthetic wire winch include safety, weight reduction, and ease of handling.

  • Safety: Synthetic winch lines are less likely to snap back under load, reducing the risk of injury during use. In the event of a breakage, synthetic fibers do not store as much energy as steel cables, minimizing the potential for dangerous recoil.
  • Weight Reduction: Synthetic wire winches are significantly lighter than their steel counterparts, making them easier to transport and install. This reduced weight is beneficial for off-road vehicles, as it can improve overall vehicle performance and handling.
  • Ease of Handling: Synthetic lines are more flexible and easier to handle, allowing for quicker spool and deployment. They are also less abrasive on hands and gear, making them user-friendly for those who frequently operate winches.
  • Durability: Synthetic winch lines are resistant to rust, corrosion, and UV damage, which can extend their lifespan. They also have better resistance to abrasion when used on rough terrains, ensuring reliability over time.
  • Less Damage to the Environment: Unlike steel cables, synthetic lines do not degrade the environment by causing metal shavings or rust pollution. This makes them a more eco-friendly choice for winching applications in sensitive areas.

How Do You Choose the Best 3000 Pound Winch for Your Needs?

The gear ratio of a winch determines how effectively it converts motor power into pulling force. A higher gear ratio means an easier pull, but it may also result in slower line speed, so finding a balance based on your needs is key.

Durability is paramount, as winches are often exposed to harsh environments. Materials like aluminum or coated steel can provide resistance to rust and wear, while additional weatherproofing can further extend the winch’s life.

Remote control options enhance usability, allowing operators to maintain a safe distance from the load being lifted. Wireless options are particularly beneficial for more extensive operations where the winch may be positioned far from the operator.

Safety features such as automatic brakes ensure that the load remains secure when not in motion, preventing accidents. Additional features like thermal protection help prevent overheating during extended use, which can prolong the lifespan of the winch.

What Features Should You Consider When Selecting a Winch?

When selecting a winch, especially the best 3000 pound winches with synthetic wire, there are several important features to consider:

  • Weight Capacity: Ensure the winch can handle at least 3000 pounds to safely pull your intended load.
  • Wire Type: Synthetic wire is preferred for its light weight, flexibility, and reduced risk of injury compared to steel cables.
  • Motor Power: Look for a winch with a powerful motor for efficient pulling without overheating or straining.
  • Gear Ratio: A higher gear ratio can provide faster line speed, making it easier to recover loads quickly.
  • Remote Control: A remote control option allows for safer operation from a distance, particularly in hazardous situations.
  • Mounting Options: Check compatibility with your vehicle or setup to ensure proper installation and stability.
  • Durability and Weather Resistance: Look for features such as sealed components and corrosion-resistant materials for longevity in various environments.
  • Braking System: A reliable braking system is crucial for load control, preventing slippage while pulling or lowering heavy items.
  • Line Length: Ensure the winch has adequate line length to reach your desired pulling point without needing extensions.

The weight capacity is fundamental to ensure that the winch can safely manage the loads you plan to use it for. Choosing a winch rated for at least 3000 pounds is essential to prevent damage and ensure safety during operation.

Wire type is another critical consideration; synthetic wire is lightweight and easier to handle, making it a popular choice. It also poses less risk of recoil if the line breaks, which is a significant safety advantage over traditional steel cables.

Motor power affects how efficiently the winch can operate under load. A strong motor will provide better performance, especially when pulling heavier items, and is less likely to overheat during prolonged use.

The gear ratio influences both the speed and torque of the winch. A higher gear ratio allows for faster line speeds, which can be beneficial for quick recoveries but may reduce pulling power, so a balance is necessary based on your needs.

A remote control feature enhances safety by allowing you to operate the winch from a distance, which is particularly useful in situations where you need to maintain a safe distance from the load being moved.

Mounting options are essential to ensure that the winch fits securely and functions correctly with your vehicle or mounting platform. Compatibility can affect both stability and ease of use.

Durability and weather resistance are critical for winches that may be used in outdoor or harsh environments. Look for models with sealed components to protect against moisture and dirt, extending the life of the winch.

A reliable braking system is vital for load control, preventing unwanted movement while in use. This feature is crucial for both safety and accuracy when pulling or lowering loads.

Finally, the line length should be sufficient for your specific applications. Insufficient line length can hinder your ability to reach the load or pulling point, making it important to check specifications before purchasing.

Why Is Build Quality Important in a 3000 Pound Winch?

Build quality plays a critical role in the performance and reliability of a 3000-pound winch, especially when using synthetic wire. Here are the key reasons why it matters:

  • Durability: High-quality materials ensure that the winch can withstand heavy loads and harsh environmental conditions. A robust build prevents premature wear and potential failure during operation, especially when dealing with challenging terrains.

  • Safety: Quality construction reduces the risk of accidents. A well-built winch is less likely to malfunction under load, safeguarding both the operator and surrounding equipment. Synthetic wire is less forgiving than steel, so a solid build minimizes the risk of snapping under strain.

  • Efficiency: Winches with superior build quality often incorporate advanced features that enhance their efficiency. They may have better gearing systems, ensuring that power is delivered effectively without overworking the motor.

  • Maintenance: A well-constructed winch often requires less maintenance over its lifespan. Sealed components and high-grade materials can resist corrosion and dirt, leading to improved longevity and reliability in the long run.

Investing in a high-quality 3000-pound winch ensures peace of mind, knowing that it can handle demanding tasks safely and effectively.

What Are the Top Brands Offering 3000 Pound Winches with Synthetic Wire?

The top brands offering 3000-pound winches with synthetic wire include:

  • Warn: Warn is renowned for its robust and reliable winches, and their 3000-pound models often come equipped with synthetic rope for enhanced safety and efficiency. These winches feature a high-performance motor and advanced braking systems, making them ideal for off-road activities and recovery tasks.
  • Smittybilt: Smittybilt provides excellent value with their 3000-pound winches, often designed for easy installation and use. Their synthetic wire winches are lightweight, reducing the overall weight of the vehicle, and are built to withstand harsh environmental conditions, ensuring durability and longevity.
  • Superwinch: Known for their commitment to quality, Superwinch offers 3000-pound winches with synthetic rope that focus on user-friendliness and efficiency. Their products often come with a wireless remote control option, allowing for greater flexibility during recovery situations.
  • Champion: Champion’s 3000-pound winches are designed for versatility and practicality, featuring synthetic wire for reduced weight and increased safety. These winches are ideal for smaller vehicles and are built with a powerful motor, ensuring reliable performance in various recovery scenarios.
  • Rugged Ridge: Rugged Ridge provides durable and high-performing 3000-pound winches with synthetic rope, tailored for off-road enthusiasts. Their winches are designed with innovative features such as sealed motors and corrosion-resistant finishes, ensuring they perform well even in challenging environments.

What Do Customer Reviews Reveal About These Winches?

Customer reviews reveal important insights about the functionality and reliability of the best 3000-pound winches with synthetic wire.

  • Performance: Many users highlight the overall performance of these winches, noting their ability to pull heavy loads smoothly and efficiently. Customers often mention the winches’ speed and reliability during critical tasks, such as towing or recovery, emphasizing that they rarely experience mechanical failures.
  • Ease of Use: Reviewers frequently comment on the user-friendly design of the winches, including features like remote controls and straightforward installation processes. This aspect is particularly appreciated by novices who may not have extensive experience with winching equipment, as it allows them to operate the winches with confidence.
  • Durability: Customers consistently mention the build quality of these winches, often praising the robust construction that withstands harsh environmental conditions. The synthetic wire is noted for its resistance to abrasion and UV damage, providing longevity that users find essential for outdoor applications.
  • Safety Features: Many reviews point out the safety features integrated into these winches, such as automatic brake systems and overload protection. Users feel reassured knowing that these winches are designed with safety in mind, helping to prevent accidents during operation.
  • Value for Money: A common theme in customer feedback is the perceived value of these winches relative to their price. Users express satisfaction with the performance and quality they receive for the cost, often stating that they would recommend these winches as a reliable investment for those needing a 3000-pound capacity.

How Can You Properly Maintain a 3000 Pound Winch with Synthetic Wire?

Proper maintenance of a 3000-pound winch with synthetic wire is essential for its longevity and performance.

  • Regular Cleaning: It is important to clean the winch and synthetic wire after each use, especially when exposed to dirt, mud, or saltwater.
  • Inspection of Synthetic Rope: Regularly inspect the synthetic wire for any signs of fraying, cuts, or abrasions, as these can compromise the rope’s strength.
  • Lubrication of Moving Parts: Keep the winch’s moving parts well-lubricated to ensure smooth operation and prevent wear over time.
  • Proper Storage: Store the winch and synthetic wire in a cool, dry place when not in use, avoiding direct sunlight to prevent UV damage.
  • Winch Operation Practices: Follow proper winching techniques, such as not exceeding the winch’s load capacity and avoiding sharp bends in the rope during operation.

Regular cleaning helps remove debris and contaminants that can cause wear and tear on the synthetic wire and the winch itself, prolonging their lifespan.

Inspection of synthetic rope is critical as even minor damage can significantly reduce its load-bearing capacity, making it essential to replace any compromised sections promptly.

Lubrication of moving parts, such as bearings and gears, reduces friction and wear, ensuring that the winch operates efficiently and extends its operational life.

Proper storage protects the winch and synthetic wire from environmental elements that can cause deterioration, such as moisture and UV rays, which can weaken the rope fibers.

Winch operation practices, including adhering to load limits and avoiding sharp bends, prevent unnecessary strain on the synthetic wire and promote safe, effective use of the winch.

What Common Uses Exist for 3000 Pound Winches with Synthetic Wire?

Common uses for 3000 pound winches with synthetic wire include:

  • Off-Road Recovery: These winches are ideal for extracting stuck vehicles from mud, sand, or steep terrains. The lightweight nature of synthetic wire makes it easier to handle and reduces the risk of injury during recovery operations.
  • Boat Trailers: A 3000 pound winch can be used to pull boats onto trailers, providing a reliable solution for securing watercraft efficiently. The synthetic wire’s resistance to abrasion and moisture helps prolong its lifespan in marine environments.
  • Utility Applications: Winches are commonly employed in various utility settings, such as lifting and pulling heavy equipment or debris. The strength of synthetic wire allows for safe operation while minimizing the weight that operators need to manage.
  • Construction Sites: These winches can assist in moving heavy materials or tools on construction sites. The synthetic wire’s durability and lightness make it a practical choice for improving safety and efficiency in lifting operations.
  • Home and Garden Projects: Homeowners often use winches for tasks like pulling tree stumps or moving large planters. The versatility of a 3000 pound winch with synthetic wire allows for easy maneuverability and handling in various residential applications.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment