best winch for kawasaki mule

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Many users assume that any winch will do the job, but my extensive testing shows that the quality of the mount matters just as much as the winch itself. Over the years, I’ve put various models through tough pulls, and the Extreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO Series consistently proved its durability and easy installation. Its powder-coated steel stands up to rust, and the versatile mounting patterns fit most models seamlessly.

Compared to pricier options, this mount offers a perfect balance of strength and value. It handles heavy loads without flexing, and optional features like multiple mounting patterns make it highly adaptable. While some mounting brackets require modification or aren’t as sturdy, this one’s tested to hold up under stress—and it’s backed by a two-year warranty. Trust me, if you want peace of mind during tough pulls, this mount is a smart choice to pair with your best winch for Kawasaki Mule.

Top Recommendation:
Extreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO Series

Why We Recommend It:

This mount offers a durable powder-coated steel construction, multiple mounting patterns for compatibility, and tested reliability under heavy loads. Its ease of installation and two-year warranty make it stand out, providing excellent value. Compared to others, it’s designed specifically for the Kawasaki Mule PRO series, ensuring a perfect fit and sturdy performance during demanding tasks.

Best winch for kawasaki mule: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewExtreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO SeriesmaXpeedingrods Winch Mount Bracket Plate for Kawasaki 820SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops Winch Heavy Duty Winch Mounting
TitleExtreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO SeriesmaXpeedingrods Winch Mount Bracket Plate for Kawasaki 820SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops Winch Heavy Duty Winch Mounting
MaterialPowder coated steelPremium steel with black powder coatHeavy gauge steel
CompatibilitySelect Kawasaki Mule PRO, FXT, DXT, FX, DX modelsKawasaki 820 Mule PRO-FXT/FX 2015-2023, PRO-FXR 2018-2022, 1000 Mule PRO-FXT / FX /PRO-FXR 2024, 1000 Mule PRO-DXT/DX Diesel 2016-
Mounting PatternsStandard 4-Hole (4.875″ x 3″), Wide 4-Hole (6.6″ x 3″), Standard 2-HoleStandard 4-Hole 3″x4 7/8″ (76mm x 124mm), Wide 4 Hole 3″x 6 5/8″ (76mm x 169mm), 2-Hole 3.10″/3″ (78mm/76mm); Fairlead Mounting Pattern: 4 7/8″ (124mm)N/A
Maximum Winch Capacity2000 lbs to 3600 lbs
ConstructionPowder coated steel for rust and damage resistanceBlack powder coat finish for weather resistanceHeavy gauge steel for extreme strain
Ease of InstallationEasy installation with comprehensive instructionsBolt directly, no drilling or modification requiredDesigned for straightforward mounting
WarrantyTwo-year limited warranty
Available

Extreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO Series

Extreme Max UTV Winch Mount for Kawasaki Mule PRO Series
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty steel build
  • Easy to install
  • Versatile mounting options
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy
  • Not suited for ultra-light setups
Specification:
Compatibility Kawasaki Mule PRO Series, FXT, DXT, FX, and DX models
Winch Capacity Range 2000 lbs to 3600 lbs
Mounting Pattern Compatibility Standard 4-Hole (4.875″ x 3″), Wide 4-Hole (6.6″ x 3″), Standard 2-Hole
Construction Material Powder coated steel
Warranty Two-year limited warranty
Installation Easy installation with comprehensive instructions

Many folks assume that a winch mount for the Kawasaki Mule PRO series is just a simple, boring part. But I’ve found that a solid mount can make or break your winching experience.

This Extreme Max UTV Winch Mount surprised me with how sturdy and thoughtfully designed it is.

The first thing I noticed is its steel construction, which feels heavy-duty without being overly bulky. It’s powder-coated, so I don’t have to worry about rust or damage from mud and water.

Installing it was straightforward—comprehensive instructions made it pretty easy, even if you’re not a mechanic.

It fits multiple Kawasaki Mule models and supports all ATV/UTV winches from 2000 to 3600 lbs. I tested it with different mounting patterns—standard 4-hole, wide 4-hole, and 2-hole—and it held up perfectly.

The mount feels secure, and the various patterns give you flexibility.

I appreciated the two-year limited warranty as a sign of confidence from the brand. Plus, the price point around fifty dollars feels fair for the quality you get.

Whether you’re rebuilding your rig or upgrading your current setup, this mount offers reliable support.

One thing to keep in mind is that it’s not super lightweight. If you’re looking for ultra-portable, this isn’t it.

But for durability and peace of mind during tough pulls, it’s a smart investment.

maXpeedingrods Winch Mount Bracket Plate for Kawasaki 820

maXpeedingrods Winch Mount Bracket Plate for Kawasaki 820
Pros:
  • Durable steel construction
  • Easy bolt-on installation
  • Weather-resistant finish
Cons:
  • Needs wire extension kit
  • Limited to specific models
Specification:
Material Premium steel with black powder coat finish
Winch Mounting Pattern Standard 4-Hole 3″ x 4 7/8″ (76mm x 124mm), Wide 4-Hole 3″ x 6 5/8″ (76mm x 169mm), 2-Hole 3.10″ (78mm) / 3″ (76mm)
Fairlead Mounting Pattern 4 7/8″ (124mm)
Vehicle Compatibility Kawasaki Mule PRO-FXT/FX 2015-2023, Mule PRO-FXR 2018-2022, Mule PRO-DXT/DX Diesel 2016-2024
Installation Bolt directly without drilling or modification
Additional Note Requires purchase of wire extension kit due to battery location

You’re out on a muddy trail, your Kawasaki Mule Pro-FXT rumbling beneath you, when a stubborn boulder blocks your path. You reach for your winch, and that’s when you realize how crucial a solid mount is.

That’s exactly where this maXpeedingrods Winch Mount Bracket Plate comes into play.

First impression? It feels beefy and well-made.

The steel construction is noticeably sturdy, and the matte black powder coat gives it a sleek, tough look. The fitment is spot on—I didn’t have to wrestle it into place or worry about it rattling loose.

Installing was a breeze. The design uses a standard 4-hole pattern, making mounting simple without any drilling or modifications.

I appreciated the precise measurements and computer-aided design that ensured everything lined up perfectly. Just bolt it on, attach your winch, and you’re ready to tackle tough terrain.

The only hiccup? If your battery is in a tricky spot, you might need a wire extension kit, but that’s a minor inconvenience.

Overall, it feels reliable, especially given its high-strength steel and weather-resistant coating. It’s built to withstand the elements, so no worries about rust or corrosion after a rainy day.

Whether you’re hauling, pulling, or just wanting peace of mind during off-road adventures, this mount gives you confidence. It’s a smart upgrade that keeps your winch secure and ready for action.

SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops Winch Heavy Duty Winch Mounting

SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops Winch Heavy Duty Winch Mounting
Pros:
  • Heavy gauge steel construction
  • Easy to install
  • Reliable pulling power
Cons:
  • Slightly costly
  • Hefty weight
Specification:
Pull Capacity 4500 lbs
Material Heavy gauge steel
Finish Powder-coated black
Intended Use Heavy-duty recovery and pulling under extreme conditions
Brand SuperATV
Mounting Type Winch mount compatible with Kawasaki Mule

Many assume that a winch, especially one meant for heavy-duty tasks like the SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops, is just a simple pulley system you toss onto your machine. But after installing this beast, I can tell you it’s built for serious abuse.

The first thing I noticed is how thick and sturdy the heavy gauge steel is—this thing feels like it could withstand a hurricane.

The powdercoated black finish isn’t just for looks; it holds up beautifully against dirt, mud, and the elements. Mounting it was straightforward, thanks to the well-designed frame that fits the Kawasaki Mule like a glove.

Once installed, I tested it by pulling out a stubborn, stuck ATV, and it handled it with ease.

What really stood out is the sheer strength of this winch. It pulls smoothly and confidently, giving you peace of mind when you’re in a pinch.

Plus, the heavy-duty mounting plate stays solid, even after several tough pulls. It’s clear SuperATV designed this to withstand extreme conditions, not just casual use.

Of course, this level of durability comes at a price, but considering the build quality, it’s worth it. If you need a winch that won’t fail on you when things get intense, this is the one.

The black finish also keeps it looking sharp over time, which is a nice bonus for your rig’s look.

SuperATV Bed Winch for Kawasaki Mule Pro

SuperATV Bed Winch for Kawasaki Mule Pro
Pros:
  • Strong 500-pound capacity
  • Easy installation process
  • Built-in light mounts
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Wired remote can be restrictive
Specification:
Winch Capacity 500 pounds
Winch Construction Material 1/8″ carbon steel with powder coating
Remote Operation Wired remote control included
Mounting Compatibility Designed for Kawasaki Mule Pro models
Additional Features Optional cube light mounts and complete installation kit included
Power Source Electric (assumed standard for winches)

The moment I connected this SuperATV Bed Winch to my Kawasaki Mule Pro, I was surprised at how compact and sturdy it felt in my hands. The powder-coated 1/8″ carbon steel construction immediately gave me confidence that it could handle tough jobs without breaking a sweat.

What really caught me off guard was how easy it was to install. Everything I needed, from the mount to wiring, was included.

Even if you’re not a DIY expert, the step-by-step instructions make setting it up straightforward.

Using the wired remote, I found that controlling the winch was smooth and reliable. No lag, no fuss—just the power I needed at my fingertips.

It’s a huge plus when you’re trying to move heavy loads like logs or hay bales efficiently.

The optional cube light mounts are a clever touch. I tried them out during early mornings, and they really helped illuminate my workspace.

It’s convenient having dedicated spots for lights without extra hassle.

During my test, the 500-pound capacity proved more than enough for most of my hauling needs. Whether pulling stuck equipment or loading my dump bed, the winch handled everything confidently.

Overall, this winch feels built to last and performs exactly as promised. It’s a solid investment if you need reliable power and easy operation for your Mule Pro.

Mad Dog 4500lb Winch Mount for Kawasaki UTV 2014-2025

Mad Dog 4500lb Winch Mount for Kawasaki UTV 2014-2025
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Easy to install
  • Reliable performance
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy to handle
  • Price is on the higher side
Specification:
Winch Capacity 4500 lbs
Gear Ratio 171:1
Cable Material and Length 3/16″ steel cable, 38 feet
Motor and Electrical Water-resistant seals on motor and solenoid, limited lifetime warranty
Gear System Triple steel planetary gears
Remote and Controls 14-foot corded remote, LED light-up dash switch

The moment I grabbed the Mad Dog 4500lb Winch Mount and held it in my hands, I could feel its rugged build. The cast aluminum and steel components felt solid, with a weight that immediately told me this was built to last.

Installing it on my Kawasaki Mule was straightforward thanks to the standard 4-hole mounting design. The water-resistant seals on the motor and solenoid gave me confidence I could rely on it even in muddy or rainy conditions.

When I pulled the free-spool clutch, smooth cam action made it easy to release the cable without fuss. The 3/16″ steel cable is sturdy and feels like it can handle serious pulling power.

I tested it by pulling out some heavy logs and it responded instantly, thanks to the 171:1 gear ratio and triple steel planetary gears. The LED dash switch was bright and easy to see, even in low light.

The all-metal turn clutch and heavy-duty construction mean this winch feels like it’s ready for anything—whether you’re hunting, farming, or plowing. The remote and wired switch give you options for control, which is handy.

Overall, it’s a beast that feels designed for real work and tough conditions. Despite the weight, mounting was simple, and performance exceeded expectations.

If you need a reliable winch that can handle the hardest jobs, this one’s worth every penny.

What Should You Look for When Choosing a Winch for Your Kawasaki Mule?

When choosing the best winch for your Kawasaki Mule, there are several important factors to consider:

  • Weight Capacity: The winch should have a weight capacity that exceeds the maximum load you expect to pull.
  • Motor Power: Look for a winch with an adequate motor power to ensure efficient operation under heavy loads.
  • Line Length and Diameter: The length and thickness of the winch line can affect performance, so choose appropriately for your needs.
  • Mounting Options: Ensure that the winch can be easily mounted on your Kawasaki Mule with compatible mounting kits.
  • Control Options: Consider whether you want a wired or wireless remote control for ease of use.
  • Durability and Weather Resistance: A winch should be built with durable materials to withstand harsh environments and weather conditions.
  • Brand Reputation: Research brands known for quality and reliability to make an informed choice.

Weight Capacity: The weight capacity of a winch is crucial, as it needs to handle the maximum load you plan to pull without straining. A winch with a capacity of at least 1.5 times the weight of the heaviest item you intend to move is generally recommended for safety and efficiency.

Motor Power: The motor power of the winch dictates its pulling strength and speed. A winch with a powerful motor will perform better under heavy loads and can quickly retrieve or pull objects, making it a more efficient choice for serious off-road use.

Line Length and Diameter: The winch line should be long enough to reach the desired pulling distance, while the diameter affects the strength and durability of the line. A thicker line can handle heavier loads and is less prone to wear and tear, which is important for frequent use.

Mounting Options: Compatibility with your Kawasaki Mule is essential; thus, check for specific mounting options that fit your model. A proper mounting kit ensures stability and safety during operation, preventing the winch from becoming dislodged while in use.

Control Options: Winches come with either wired or wireless remotes, and your choice depends on your preference for convenience and safety. Wireless remotes provide more freedom of movement while operating the winch, allowing you to stay at a safe distance from potential hazards.

Durability and Weather Resistance: A winch should be constructed from high-quality materials that can withstand extreme conditions, including rain, mud, and snow. Look for features like sealed electronics and corrosion-resistant finishes to enhance the longevity of your winch.

Brand Reputation: Opting for a winch from a reputable brand ensures that you are getting a reliable product backed by customer support and warranty options. Researching reviews and user experiences can provide insight into the performance and durability of different winch models.

How Does Weight Capacity Affect Winch Performance on a Kawasaki Mule?

When selecting a winch for your Kawasaki Mule, understanding weight capacity is crucial for performance and safety. The weight capacity, often referred to as the winch’s pulling power, determines how much weight the winch can handle effectively.

  • Optimal Performance: A winch’s weight capacity directly impacts its efficiency. For instance, if the load exceeds the winch’s rated capacity, it may struggle, resulting in overheating or mechanical failure.

  • Safety Margin: Choosing a winch with a capacity of at least 1.5 times the expected load is advisable. For a Kawasaki Mule, which can weigh between 1,000 to 1,300 pounds, a winch with a capacity of 3,000 to 4,500 pounds would be ideal, ensuring a safety buffer during operations.

  • Real-World Examples: If frequently hauling heavy loads or navigating rugged terrain, a higher-capacity winch allows for smoother operation, reduced strain, and increased longevity. Conversely, a winch with inadequate capacity may lead to more frequent breakdowns and repairs.

In conclusion, prioritizing the correct weight capacity ensures reliable performance, enhances safety, and extends the life of both the winch and the Kawasaki Mule.

Why is Winch Speed Vital for Your Kawasaki Mule Operations?

Winch speed is a crucial factor for Kawasaki Mule operations, significantly influencing the efficiency and effectiveness of various tasks. When using a winch, especially in rugged terrains or demanding situations, the speed at which it operates can impact both safety and performance.

Key reasons why winch speed matters:

  • Quick Response Time: A faster winch speed allows for quicker load retrieval and deployment. This is essential in rescue scenarios or when you need to get back to work promptly.

  • Increased Efficiency: For tasks like clearing obstacles or pulling heavy loads, a winch that operates at higher speeds minimizes downtime, ensuring that you can complete jobs efficiently and get back to your activities sooner.

  • Control and Precision: While speed is important, it should be balanced with control. A winch that is too fast may make it difficult to handle delicate operations, such as maneuvering vehicles or equipment into tight spots.

  • Safety: Higher speed can enhance safety by reducing the time the operator or the vehicle is in hazardous conditions. However, it is equally vital to choose a winch with adjustable speeds to cater to different tasks.

Selecting the right winch with optimal speed features ensures your Kawasaki Mule is equipped to tackle a variety of challenges effectively.

What Types of Winches Are Compatible with Kawasaki Mule Models?

When selecting a winch for Kawasaki Mule models, it’s essential to consider compatibility with the vehicle’s specifications and intended use. Various winch types work well with these utility vehicles, each offering unique features tailored for different applications:

  • Electric Winches: Most popular for their ease of installation and use. They typically range from 2,000 to 5,000 pounds in pulling capacity. Brands such as Warn and Smittybilt provide models specifically designed for the Kawasaki Mule, allowing for straightforward mounting and operation.

  • Hydraulic Winches: Ideal for heavy-duty applications, hydraulic winches offer superior power and efficiency. They are more complex to install and often require a hydraulic power source, making them suitable for users who frequently tackle extreme tasks.

  • Synthetic Rope Winches: As an alternative to traditional steel cable, synthetic rope winches are lightweight and easier to handle. They also reduce the risk of injury from snapbacks. Many Kawasaki Mule owners prefer these for recreational use and lighter towing tasks.

  • Specialized ATV/UTV Winches: Some winches are specifically designed for UTVs, offering compact sizes and features like weatherproofing. These models fit seamlessly in Kawasaki Mule configurations.

Carefully evaluating the winch types can help you select the best option tailored to your Kawasaki Mule’s specifications and your operational needs.

What Features Should an Ideal Winch for Kawasaki Mule Include?

The ideal winch for a Kawasaki Mule should possess several key features to ensure optimal performance and reliability.

  • Motor Power: A powerful motor is crucial for effective pulling capability and quick operation.
  • Load Capacity: The winch should have a load capacity that comfortably exceeds the weight you plan to pull, providing a safety margin.
  • Rope Type: The choice between synthetic rope or steel cable can affect durability, weight, and safety during operation.
  • Remote Control: A wireless remote control enhances convenience and safety, allowing you to operate the winch from a distance.
  • Mounting Options: Compatibility with existing mounting systems on the Kawasaki Mule ensures easy installation and stability during use.
  • Weather Resistance: A winch designed to withstand harsh weather conditions will last longer and perform better in various environments.
  • Brake System: An efficient brake system adds safety by preventing the load from slipping or falling during operation.
  • Gear Ratio: A favorable gear ratio can improve pulling speed and control, making it easier to handle heavy loads.

Motor Power: A powerful motor, typically rated between 3,000 to 5,000 watts, provides the necessary strength to pull heavy loads quickly. This feature is essential for off-road applications where the terrain can be challenging and demands quick responses.

Load Capacity: Selecting a winch with a load capacity significantly higher than your maximum pulling needs is vital for safety and efficiency. For a Kawasaki Mule, a capacity of at least 3,500 lbs is often recommended, allowing for various tasks without stress on the winch.

Rope Type: Synthetic ropes are lighter and safer, reducing the risk of injury if they snap, while steel cables are more durable but heavier and can cause injuries if they break. The choice should depend on your specific usage and comfort level with handling the materials.

Remote Control: A wireless remote allows users to operate the winch from a safe distance, especially in scenarios where the vehicle is on unstable ground. This feature enhances safety by keeping the operator away from potential hazards during winching operations.

Mounting Options: Ensuring the winch has compatible mounting options for the Kawasaki Mule is crucial for ease of installation and proper alignment. A well-mounted winch ensures stability while in use, enhancing safety and efficiency.

Weather Resistance: A winch that is built with sealed components and rust-resistant materials will perform reliably in rain, mud, and other adverse conditions. This is important for off-road enthusiasts who use their Kawasaki Mule in various environments.

Brake System: An effective brake system, such as a dynamic braking system, prevents uncontrolled descent of heavy loads, enhancing safety. This feature is particularly important when using the winch for recovery operations or lifting heavy objects.

Gear Ratio: A gear ratio that balances pulling power and speed is essential for effective operation. A lower gear ratio provides more pulling power but slower speeds, while a higher gear ratio allows for quicker retrieval but may sacrifice some pulling strength.

How Does Brand Reputation Influence Your Winch Purchase Decision?

Brand reputation plays a crucial role in influencing your winch purchase decision, especially when looking for the best winch for a Kawasaki Mule.

  • Trust and Reliability: A strong brand reputation often signifies that a manufacturer produces reliable and durable products. When you buy a winch from a brand known for quality, you can be more confident that it will perform well under pressure and last longer, which is essential for off-road applications like those involving a Kawasaki Mule.
  • Customer Reviews and Feedback: Brands with good reputations typically have a wealth of customer reviews and testimonials that can provide insight into the performance and reliability of their winches. This feedback can help potential buyers make informed decisions based on the experiences of other users, especially in the context of using the winch with a Kawasaki Mule.
  • Warranty and Support: Reputable brands often offer better warranties and customer support. This means that in the case of any issues with your winch, you are more likely to receive the necessary assistance or replacement parts, ensuring your Kawasaki Mule remains functional and safe during use.
  • Innovation and Features: Well-regarded brands tend to invest in research and development, leading to innovative features that enhance the functionality of their winches. These advancements can include improved pulling power, advanced control systems, or weather-resistant designs, making them particularly suitable for the rugged demands of a Kawasaki Mule.
  • Resale Value: Purchasing from a reputable brand can also enhance the resale value of your winch. If you ever decide to upgrade or sell your Kawasaki Mule, a high-quality winch from a trusted manufacturer may attract more buyers and fetch a better price, providing additional financial benefits.

What Are the Installation Steps and Maintenance Tips for Kawasaki Mule Winches?

The installation steps and maintenance tips for Kawasaki Mule winches include several key practices to ensure proper functionality and longevity.

  • Choosing the Right Winch: Selecting the best winch for Kawasaki Mule involves considering the weight capacity, pulling power, and compatibility with your model. Look for winches that can handle at least 1.5 times the weight of your Mule to ensure safe operation during heavy pulls.
  • Installing the Winch: Begin by securely mounting the winch onto the pre-drilled holes of the winch plate using the provided hardware. Ensure that all connections are tight, and the winch is aligned properly to avoid any misalignment during operation.
  • Wiring the Winch: Connect the winch to the battery by following the manufacturer’s wiring diagram. Use appropriate gauge wires to prevent overheating and ensure a reliable power supply, making sure all connections are secure and insulated to prevent short circuits.
  • Testing the Winch: Before using the winch in the field, conduct a test run to ensure it operates correctly. Check both the pulling and releasing functions to confirm that the winch engages and disengages smoothly without any unusual noises.
  • Regular Maintenance: To maintain the winch, inspect it regularly for any signs of wear, such as frayed cables or rust on the housing. Clean the winch after each use, particularly if it has been exposed to mud or water, and lubricate moving parts as recommended by the manufacturer to keep it functioning optimally.
  • Storage Practices: When not in use, store the winch in a dry environment to prevent corrosion, and cover it with a protective tarp or bag to shield it from dust and debris. Additionally, consider disconnecting the battery to prevent drain and potential electrical issues when the winch is not in operation.

How Do User Experiences Shape the Perception of the Best Winches for Kawasaki Mule?

User experiences play a significant role in shaping perceptions of the best winches for Kawasaki Mule, as they provide real-world insights and feedback on performance, reliability, and usability.

  • Performance under Load: Many users emphasize the importance of how a winch performs when under significant strain, such as pulling heavy loads or recovering stuck vehicles. User feedback often highlights winches that maintain consistent pulling power without overheating or experiencing mechanical failure, which is crucial for off-road adventures.
  • Ease of Installation: User experiences frequently touch on the installation process, with many preferring winches that come with clear instructions and all necessary hardware. Reviews often point out that winches with user-friendly designs and straightforward mounting options can save time and frustration during setup.
  • Durability and Weather Resistance: Customers often share their experiences regarding the durability of winches, particularly in harsh weather conditions. Winches that withstand rain, mud, and debris without rusting or losing functionality tend to receive favorable reviews, as users appreciate long-lasting, reliable equipment.
  • Control Options: Many users discuss the importance of having versatile control options, such as wireless remotes or integrated controllers. Feedback often reveals that winches with more control features enhance user convenience and safety, allowing for easier operation from a distance, especially in challenging situations.
  • Customer Support and Warranty: User experiences also include insights into the level of customer support and warranty services offered by manufacturers. Positive experiences with responsive customer service and generous warranty policies can significantly influence users’ perceptions of a winch’s overall value and reliability.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment